Loudness in string instruments is shaped by physics, acoustics, and perception. Instruments sounding loud to players often project well in halls.
Perceiving loudness is an intricate dance between physics, psychology, and acoustics. Stringed instruments, particularly violins, violas, and cellos, add layers of complexity to this dance, given their distinctive mechanics of producing sound and the settings they are most often played in.
An enduring assumption among musicians and listeners is that these instruments may seem gentle to the performer—'under the ear'—but can permeate powerfully through a concert hall. A significant study by Dr. Claudia Fritz, a notable name in the sphere of musical acoustics, and Joseph Curtin, a distinguished violin craftsman, brings this long-held belief into question.
Before we delve into the findings of the study, let's touch base with some fundamentals of sound and the perception of loudness.
Sound is a type of energy that travels in waves. These waves are characterized by distinct frequencies, measured in Hertz (Hz), with our auditory system being particularly attuned to frequencies in the 2000 - 5000 Hz range. The duration of a sound also factors into how loud it is perceived—a concept known as temporal integration.
Thus, our sense of loudness isn't solely about the physical energy or the amplitude of the sound wave; it's a more nuanced process, influenced by an array of elements and our individual auditory traits.
When we think of string instruments, the perception of the performer and that of the audience can differ owing to their proximity to the source and the impact of the acoustics of the space. The performer, positioned close to the instrument, hears an intricate range of sounds which can seem softer. Conversely, an audience in a concert hall hears a resonant, amplified sound, which can come across as louder.
The study led by Fritz and Curtin invited 55 experienced violinists to evaluate twelve violins—six antique Italian and six modern—first in a silent room and then in a concert hall.
In the silent room, violinists performed on the instruments while wearing welding goggles and being surrounded by diffusive screens, reducing visual and tactile identification. Later, in the concert hall, they selected the four violins they preferred most and rated them for their projection capability.
A strong correlation emerged between the instruments favored in the silent room and those considered to project well in the concert hall. This inferred that if an instrument seems loud to the performer, it is also likely to sound loud in the concert hall, counteracting the idea that an instrument can sound gentle 'under the ear' but resonate powerfully in a concert hall.
Even though lower frequencies, with their extended wavelengths, have the potential to travel further, this doesn't necessarily correlate with an increase in perceived loudness for audience members in a concert hall. The impact of room acoustics and the frequency response of the human ear play pivotal roles in shaping this perception.
While Fritz and Curtin's study doesn't negate these influences, it offers an added layer of understanding. It suggests that the performer's perception of an instrument's loudness, even in a quiet setting, can be indicative of how the instrument will project in a larger, more echoey space.
In conclusion, deciphering the loudness in string instruments involves a sophisticated interplay of sound physics, individual auditory characteristics, instrument acoustics, and environmental factors. Research like that undertaken by Fritz and Curtin gives us a deeper understanding and appreciation of these subtleties. While the belief that an instrument can sound gentle to the player but resonate powerfully in a concert hall has been scrutinized, the exploration of loudness and projection remains a captivating field of study in acoustics and music.
This exploration into the complexities of loudness perception in string instruments such as violins, violas, and cellos serves as merely an introduction to this captivating topic. The interplay between sound physics, individual hearing characteristics, instrument acoustics, and room environment is multifaceted and extends well beyond the scope of this article. For those interested in diving deeper into the subject, you might consider further reading such as "The Physics of the Violin" by Lothar Cremer, "The Science of String Instruments" edited by Thomas D. Rossing, or "Musical Acoustics" by Donald Hall. Additionally, academic articles like those published by Dr. Claudia Fritz and Joseph Curtin can offer more specialized insights. Delving into these resources will further your understanding and appreciation of the acoustics and perception of musical instruments.
MyLuthier was started by two friends while they were studying at the Royal Academy of Music in London. The idea was to provide musicians with exceptional instruments at a price they can afford. We travelled Europe in search for the best contemporary makers and we’re proud of our selection and the partnerships we’ve developed.